Follow-up: Cardinals respond to the british euthanasia for disabled newborns debate

Some people in the combox of the blog post "Does the Church of England support Infant Euthanasia or not?" asked why the Catholic heirarchy has been silent on the debate. Today, Cardinals Barragan and Lozano stood up:

Speaking with Italian reporters, Cardinal Javier Lozano Barragan, president of the Pontifical Council for Health Care, deplored the "cruelty" of a proposal to allow newborns with severe handicapped to be euthanized in the United Kingdom.

The cardinal noted that the position of the Church "is unchanged, life does not belong to man but to the Lord. The life of an innocent being cannot be taken either by direct or indirect means. Euthanasia is never permissible. This goes for the terminally ill and for children, including those born with serious problems."

According to Cardinal Lozano, "Ending the life of an innocent person, even if it is a premature baby who is gravely ill, is the equivalent of euthanasia, and this is an illicit action, as well as an act of cruelty."

He also stressed that the "Catholic Church does not impose, she proposes her doctrine," as the "dignity of the human person is based on the primordial principle that is human life and that we defend from beginning to end."

Cardinal Lozano also emphasized that the Church does not teach that doctors must use disproportionate means or medicines that will only prolong the agony of a person who would otherwise be close to death. "Nobody should be obliged to accept this kind of therapy," he said. "But in the case that is being presented here, we are dealing with murder. We must remember that the fifth commandment says, Thou shalt not kill."

In Great Britain, Anglican Bishop Tom Butler of Southwark said his church would not support the euthanasia for newborns and he called for distinctions to be made between euthanasia and the rejection of extraordinary means. [CNA]

A very nice clear and concise exposition of Catholic teaching. And the last paragraph seems to agree with my evaluation of Butler's position. Please God his words are heeded by the doctors ...